When was Harry Potter born?
In the first book, on page 43, Dudley says "Its monday. The Great Humberto's on tonight. I want to stay somewhere with a television."
On page 45, it says, "the lighted dial of Dudley's watch told Harry that he would be 11 in 10 minutes time."
This would mean that Harry's birthday, well known to be July 31, would fall on a Tuesday. Out of the last 30 years, in only 3 of them does July 31 fall on a Tuesday. These years are 1984, 1990, 2001.
This, however, is contradicted by book 2 where Harry celebrates Nearly-Headless-Nick's 500th deathday party and sees a cake that says that he died October 31, 1492. This would make the present date in book 2 1992. If the first theory was right, Harry would have started his third year in 1992. Also, according to the Harry Potter Lexicon,
"In book four, Harry tells Sirius that his cousin threw his Playstation out the window. Sony released the first Playstation in December of 1994, and that was in Japan. If we accept the timeline derived from the Deathday Party cake, Harry is telling Sirius about this incident in July of 1994, a half-year earlier."
So unless nearly headless Nick is getting senile in his old death, and Duddley has a Japanese Playstation there is a contradiction. I think that his is in fact the best way, because Rowling obviously wanted her stories to be timeless. It is interesting though; The dates almost fit, but not quite. This is perfectly in line with the spirit of the books. They took place some time in the recent past, we just don't know exactly when.
2 Comments:
Rowling is good a the details but not obsesive. I doubt she figured out the on which year July 31 fell on Tuesday or really worried about when the Playstation was introduced. Thus your 'timelessness". Even the obsesive Tolkien, who worked out these types of issues for the Lord of the Rings in amazing detail, made an occasional error. And Tolkien spent a lifetime work his mythology.
Another thought about Harry Potter - The name Voldemort perhaps means of "path of death" - Vol can mean lane or way in French
Post a Comment
<< Home